Persistent pop-ups? Not a good idea

Written by Adrian Holovaty on January 13, 2004

An E-Media Tidbits post today suggested that news sites might benefit from the technique of spawning pop-up windows when readers click away to other sites. "Use this window to go back to the article you were just reading," the pop-up might say.

Fundamentally, this idea isn't half bad. It's too easy, especially for patience-deprived surfers like me, to click an offsite link and forget one's position in the previous site. Sure, that's what the Back button and History are for, but those tools can get hairy -- particularly when surfing in a tabbed browser. I can see some good in a Web site that remembers what I did last.

But the pop-up implementation? Horrid. Maybe -- and that's a big maybe -- it's appropriate for critical, transaction-based applications, where it's vital that you leave your browser open to a particular site before you complete, e.g., a multi-page purchase. But do we really want this for news? With few exceptions, it essentially would mean that clicking any external link (your bookmarks, your e-mail client, in-page external links) would result in a rather intrusive popped-up message:

"Hey! You're leaving our site! But we'll stick around in this pop-up window just in case you ever decide to come back. You know. Just in case you forget our URL."

If news sites are going to start keeping track of the last article I read, they'd best do it on their servers. Not on my precious desktop space. Set a cookie, and use it to display relevant session-based data directly in the page layout -- as does. Don't pop up.


Posted by kpaul on January 15, 2004, at 5:21 a.m.:

I use history a lot (both in real life and in my browser ;)

I had to adjust a little when tabs appeared, but I still hold down the back button to get the history list every now and then.

Yeah, pop-ups are bad, but I still have to preach against their use at work.

Instead of pop-ups and bigger banners, news orgs need to make their sites smarter - personalization, personalization, personalization...

That, and start investing in online again.

I read a thread tonight on webmasterworld by someone who said he knew more than a few people who were making five figures on their own per month (a lot to do with adsense - newspapers need to take a long, hard look at Google and how they do things - they're both information companies, no?)

Anyway, a lot of savvy independents are out there investing this new cash flow (adwords, adsense, contextual, etc.) in writers and artists and programmers. Newspapers (and even radio and television stations) laugh these sites off, but keep your eye on them. Remember the effects the printing press and desktop publishing had on the world. The Internet is still new ... newspapers have a long way to go to maintain their dominance in the online realm.

my two bytes,


Comments have been turned off for this page.